Warning: this post contains spoilers from the season 5 finale of Lost.
In the season 5 finale of Lost, Jack Shepard faces an ethical dilemma. Daniel Faraday, a scientist on the island, told Jack of a plan that could possibly rewrite history and prevent Jack’s group from ever crashing on the island (you know, effectively reversing seasons 1 through 5 of the show). This is really attractive to Jack, because he could prevent a lot of suffering that (presumably) didn’t need to happen.
But here’s the clincher. Jack’s hot friend Kate thinks that Daniel’s plan is going to blow up the entire island and kill everyone once and for all.
Who is right? Jack has to make a snap decision. Yet he struggles because he’s faced with two right choices — fixing something that wasn’t his fault or leaving everything alone and finding another way.
Right versus right decisions.
Jack’s decision is similar to many of ours. We’re not always choosing between black and white, good and evil. And when we are, these choices are usually easy.
The most difficult decisions occur when we’re placed in situations where either choice is good. It seems that not even our consciences can reason through these dilemmas, because both are correct.
Do we give money to a charity or to a church? Which of two equally qualified job candidates do we hire? Do we tell a white lie to protect someone’s feelings or be honest with them to maintain our integrity?
Fortunately, we can navigate our way through almost any decision with three short (but not so easy) questions.
1. Who am I?
The first place of inspection should be yourself. What kind of a person are you? If you were a character in a movie, what would you expect yourself to do?
To use the previous example, when deciding to give money to a church or a charity, ask yourself if you’re a church person or a charity person. When making a decision between your career and your family, ask yourself whether you’re a career person or a family person.
The answer to this question doesn’t always come easily. But this type of introspection will give you a new perspective to grasp the problem more clearly.
2. Who do I want to become?
Still, it’s not enough to merely put yourself into this box or that. Maybe you’re not only a career person or only a family person. If you find your arms in two different shirts, you might be stuck in a quandary.
That’s when you ask yourself who you are trying to become. If you want to become an honest businessperson, perhaps you should refund the money that your client was overcharged. If you want to be a family person, perhaps you shouldn’t take the accounts that keep you at work late.
3. What would someone I love think about my choice?
If you’re a parent, how would your kid feel about your decision? I know it’s trite, but what would your mother say about your choice?
If your heart hasn’t been seared with a hot iron yet, this question will definitely crank up the heat.
Finally, allow the dilemma to define you.
At the end of the episode, Jack decides to follow Daniel’s plan. He decides that he’s going to be the hero that makes everything right. He defines himself with that final decision.
In the end, we see that Jack’s plan definitely blows something up — but is it the island? Or something completely different? We don’t know yet. An entire nation has been white-knuckling their TV remotes for months now. If you don’t believe me, go search Twitter.
But no matter what the ending of the story is, the above three questions work because they get at the heart of the problem. They tell you who you are and allow you to recognize how your decision changes that.
And here’s a surprise: when making right-versus-right choices, it often doesn’t matter what you choose in the end. Knowing who you are and staying true to what you want to become is most important. As Billy Shakespeare put it, “This above all: to thine own self be true, And it must follow, as the night the day, Thou canst not then be false to any man.”